What the calculator compares
At the end of each year, the buyer has the home's value minus selling costs, minus whatever is left on the mortgage, plus any savings built up when owning costs less than renting. The renter has the down payment and closing costs invested, plus the monthly difference invested when renting costs less than owning. The larger number is ahead in this model.
That framing matters. A mortgage payment builds equity, but it also carries interest, property tax, insurance, maintenance and transaction costs. Renting has no equity, but it can leave more money invested each month and avoids the cost of buying and selling.
An example with the advanced costs on
A $350,000 home with 20% down at 6.5% over 30 years has a mortgage payment of about $1,769.79. Add property tax, insurance, maintenance and the deposit, and the first month of owning costs roughly $2,453 against $1,800 of rent.
With 3% appreciation, 5% selling costs, 3% annual rent increases and a 5% return on the invested difference, the buyer's projected wealth after 10 years is about $209,000 and the renter's is about $210,000. It is close, and the result flips with different assumptions. That is the point: run your own numbers, and look at the break-even year rather than a single verdict.
The assumptions that move the answer most
- How long you stay. Buying costs are paid up front; a short stay rarely recovers them.
- Appreciation. A high rate makes buying look better, and it is the assumption most often overestimated.
- Rent increases. Faster rent growth helps the buying case over time.
- Investment return. A higher return on the renter's savings helps renting.
- Maintenance and taxes. These are real ownership costs and do not build equity.
What is not included
- Moving costs, renovations, special assessments and HOA special levies.
- Changes in income, interest rates or the ability to refinance.
- The non-financial value of a home: stability, control and a place to live.
- Tax rules that vary by country and change over time.
Use the house or car calculator if you only want the payment and net worth with and without the purchase, and the loan calculator for the mortgage schedule alone.
Frequently asked questions
What does the calculator compare?
The wealth you would have after each year buying and selling, against renting and investing the difference.
Why does buying sometimes look worse?
Transaction costs, taxes, maintenance and the opportunity cost of the deposit can outweigh the equity built over a short horizon.
What is a break-even year?
The first year the buyer's projected wealth matches or passes the renter's.
Is this a recommendation?
No. It is a projection based on the assumptions you enter.